Written by Luke Broadwater and Alan Feuer
The House committee investigating the January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol made a wide-ranging case Monday that former President Donald Trump created and relentlessly spread the lie that the 2020 election had been stolen from him in the face of mounting evidence from an expanding chorus of advisers that he had been legitimately defeated.
The committee, in its second hearing this month, traced the origins and progression of what it has described as Trump’s “big lie.” It showed through live witness testimony and recorded depositions how the former president, defying many of his advisers, insisted on declaring victory on election night before the votes were fully counted, then sought to challenge his defeat with increasingly outlandish and baseless claims that he was repeatedly informed were wrong.
“He’s become detached from reality if he really believes this stuff,” Bill Barr, the former attorney general, said of Trump during a videotaped interview the panel played Monday, in which he at one point could not control his laughter at the absurdity of the claims that the former president was making.
“There was never an indication of interest in what the actual facts were,” Barr said.
The panel also used the testimony of Bill Stepien, Trump’s campaign chief, who told its investigators that Trump had ignored his election-night warning to refrain from declaring a victory that he had no basis for claiming. Instead, the president took the advice of Rudy Giuliani — his personal lawyer who was, according to Jason Miller, a top campaign aide, “definitely intoxicated” — and said he had won even as the votes were still being tabulated.
Trump lost the election, knew he lost, yet continued to claim the election was ‘stolen’ and spread the Big Lie.
Watch the Select Committee’s hearing 2 recap ⤵️ pic.twitter.com/CQOXUKjLc6
— January 6th Committee (@January6thCmte) June 13, 2022
It was all part of the committee’s bid to show how Trump’s dissembling about the election results led directly to the events of January 6, when a mob of his supporters stormed the Capitol in the deadliest attack on the building in centuries, spurred on by the president’s exhortations to “stop the steal.”
Investigators went further Monday, detailing how the Trump campaign and its Republican allies used claims of a rigged election that they knew were false to mislead small donors and raise as much as $250 million for an entity they called the Official Election Defense Fund, which top campaign aides testified never existed.
“Not only was there the big lie,” said Rep Zoe Lofgren, D-California, who played a key role in the hearing, “there was the big rip-off.”
Money ostensibly raised to “stop the steal” instead went to Trump and his allies, including, the investigation found, $1 million for a charitable foundation run by Mark Meadows, his chief of staff; $1 million to a political group run by several of his former staff members, including Stephen Miller, architect of Trump’s immigration agenda; more than $200,000 to Trump hotels; and $5 million to Event Strategies Inc., which ran the January 6 rally that preceded the Capitol riot.
Bill Stepien, the final chairman of former President Donald Trump’s campaign, listens to Trump speak at his campaign headquarters in Arlington, Va., November 3, 2020. (Anna Moneymaker/The New York Times)
Aides said Kimberly Guilfoyle, girlfriend of Trump’s son Donald Trump Jr, was paid $60,000 to speak at that event, a speech that lasted less than three minutes.
“It is clear that he intentionally misled his donors, asked them to donate to a fund that didn’t exist and used the money raised for something other than what he said,” Lofgren said of Trump.
But the bulk of the session was dedicated to showing how determined Trump was to cling to the fiction that he had won the election, only digging in more deeply as aide after aide informed him that he had not.
The list of aides and advisers who sought to steer Trump away from his false claims was long and varied, according to the committee’s presentation. They included low-level campaign lawyers who outlined how they told the president that the returns coming in from the field showed that he was going to lose the race. Also among them were top officials in the Justice Department — including his onetime attorney general — who walked through how they had investigated claims that the race had been rigged or stolen and found them not only to be unsubstantiated but also to be nonsensical.
“I remember he delivered to the President in pretty blunt terms that he was going to lose.” – Jason Miller, a senior Trump Campaign spokesperson pic.twitter.com/F8uxTV9cyt
— January 6th Committee (@January6thCmte) June 10, 2022
“There were suggestions by, I believe it was Mayor Giuliani, to go and declare victory and say that we’d won it outright,” Miller said in a video interview played by the panel.
Stepien later said he considered himself part of “Team Normal,” while a separate group of outside advisers including Giuliani were encouraging Trump’s bogus claims.
The committee played several portions of a deposition by Barr, Trump’s last attorney general, who called the president’s claims of a stolen election “bullshit” and “bogus.”
“I told them that it was crazy stuff and they were wasting their time,” Barr testified. “And it was a great, great disservice for the country.”
Trump was still at it Monday, issuing a rambling 12-page statement several hours after the committee hearing ended in which he doubled down on his claims of fraud, complaining — yet again without any evidence — that Democrats had inflated voter rolls, illegally harvested ballots, removed Republican poll watchers from vote-counting facilities, bribed election officials and stopped the counting on election night when he was still in the lead.
Al Schmidt, a member of the Philadelphia board that supervises voter registration and elections, in Philadelphia, October 27, 2020. (Michelle Gustafson/The New York Times)
“Democrats created the narrative of January 6 to detract from the much larger and more important truth that the 2020 Election was rigged and stolen,” Trump wrote.
In the hearing room Monday, the panel showed in striking detail how Trump’s advisers tried and failed to get him to drop his lies and accept defeat. In his deposition, Barr recalled several scenes inside the White House, including one in which he said he asked Meadows and Jared Kushner, the president’s son-in-law and top adviser, how long Trump intended “to go on with this stolen election stuff.”
Barr recalled that Meadows had assured him that Trump was “becoming more realistic” and knew “how far he can take this.” As for Kushner, Barr recounted that he responded to the question by saying, “We’re working on this.”
After informing Trump that his claims of fraud were false, Barr had a follow-up meeting with the president and his White House counsel, Pat Cipollone. Barr described in his deposition how Trump became enraged that his own attorney general had refused to back his fraud allegations.
“This is killing me,” Barr quoted Trump as saying. “You must have said this because you hate Trump.”
Altogether, Trump and his allies filed more than 60 lawsuits challenging the results of the election. But among the numerous claims of fraud, Barr told the committee, the worst — and most sensational — concerned a purported plot by Chinese software companies, Venezuelan officials and liberal financier George Soros to hack into machines manufactured by Dominion Voting Systems and flip votes away from Trump.
These allegations were most prominently pushed by Sidney Powell, a former federal prosecutor who collected several unvetted affidavits from witnesses who supposedly had information about Dominion. In the weeks after the election, Powell, working with a group of other lawyers, filed four federal lawsuits laying out her claims in the Democratic strongholds of Atlanta, Detroit, Milwaukee and Phoenix even though the Trump campaign had already determined that some of her allegations were false.
All of the suits — known as the “Krakens,” a reference to a mythical, havoc-wreaking sea beast — were eventually dismissed and deemed to be so frivolous that a federal judge sanctioned Powell and her colleagues. Dominion has sued her and others for defamation.
Barr, in his deposition, described the claims against Dominion as “crazy stuff” — a sentiment that was echoed by other Trump aides whose testimony was presented by the committee.
After Barr left his position as attorney general, his successor, Jeffrey Rosen, also told Trump his claims of widespread fraud were “debunked.”
Another witness who testified Monday and dismissed Trump’s claims of fraud was Byung J Pak, the former US attorney in Atlanta who abruptly resigned on January 4, 2021. After speaking with Barr, Pak looked into allegations of election fraud in Atlanta, including a claim pushed by Giuliani that a suitcase of ballots had been pulled from under a table in a local counting station on election night.
Trump and his allies also claimed that there was rampant fraud in Philadelphia, with the former president recently asserting that more people voted in the city than there were registered voters. In his deposition, Barr called this allegation “rubbish.” To bolster this argument, the committee called Al Schmidt, a Republican who served as one of three city commissioners on the Philadelphia County Board of Elections.
Schmidt rejected the fraud claims raised by Trump and his allies, saying there was no evidence that more people voted in Philadelphia than were registered there or that thousands of dead people voted in the city.
Best of Express Premium
PremiumUPSC Key-June 14, 2022: Why ‘Due Process of Law’ to ‘5G…
PremiumAmid ED summons to Rahul, Congress faces tough choice: cry foul or cry hard
Premium‘It is an absolute joy’: Metaverse celebrates inclusivity thi…
PremiumAverage math score of first-year engineering students below 40%: AICTEMore Premium Stories >>
Schmidt also testified that after Trump posted a tweet accusing of him by name of committing election fraud, he received threats online from people who publicised the names of his family members, his address and photographs of his home.
